X

Download Forced treatment of anorexia nervosa PowerPoint Presentation


Login   OR  Register
X

Share page



  Preview

               
Home / Health & Wellness / Health & Wellness Presentations / Forced treatment of anorexia nervosa PowerPoint Presentation

Forced treatment of anorexia nervosa PowerPoint Presentation

slidesfinder By : slidesfinder

On : Mar 14, 2014

facebook   twitter   google plus  
In : Health & Wellness

Embed :
574
views

0
downloads
Login / Signup - with account for


  • → Make favorite
  • → Flag as inappropriate
  • → Download Presentation
  • → Share Presentation
  • Slide 1 - Coercion and the treatment of anorexia nervosa © Copyright 2010
  • Slide 2 - The ethical dilemma Consent is the bedrock of medical treatment Patients with anorexia nervosa (AN) don’t believe that they have a problem and therefore refuse treatment Should physicians a) treat patients who do not consent; or b) not treat, possibly leading to morbidity and death
  • Slide 3 - What is anorexia nervosa? Anorexia nervosa is defined as: Intense fear of weight gain Weight consistently <85th% for age and height (In women) three consecutive missed periods Together with one of following: refusal to admit seriousness of weight loss undue influence of shape or weight on one’s self-image disturbed experience in one’s shape or weight DSM-IV-TR
  • Slide 4 - Incidence Overall U.S. .3 to 1% Women 4% Men .1% Harvard Mental Health Letter. Oct/Nov 1997.
  • Slide 5 - Fatality rate Estimates of fatality rate: 4% to 18% (Rate tends to increase given longer duration of illness) Crow SJ. Am J of Psychiatry. 2009. Sullivan PF. Am J of Psychiatry. 1995. Harvard Mental Health Letter. Oct./Nov 1997.
  • Slide 6 - 50 years of treatment outcomes Comparison of outcomes 1950-1999 to gauge whether any improvement over time 119 studies conducted 1950-1999 5,590 patients, adolescents and adults Follow-ups clustered into three time frames: < 4 years after hospitalization 4-10 years >10 years after Steinhausen HC. Am J Psychiatry. 2002.
  • Slide 7 - 50 years of treatment outcomes 577 patients had <4 years of follow-up 2,132 had 4–10 years of follow-up 438 had >10 years of follow-up Steinhausen HC. Am J Psychiatry. 2002.
  • Slide 8 - Outcome measures Broad outcome measures: death, recovery, improvement, chronicity Symptom normalization measures: weight, menstruation, eating behavior Psychopathologies such as affective disorders, OCD, anxiety, substance abuse Steinhausen HC. Am J Psychiatry. 2002
  • Slide 9 - “The mortality rate was much lower in the group of younger patients than that in the group with a much wider age at onset of illness. The rates of recovery, improvement, and chronicity were more favorable in the group with the younger patients.” Steinhausen HC. Am J Psychiatry. 2002
  • Slide 10 - “Anorexia nervosa did not lose its relatively poor prognosis in the 20th century.” Steinhausen HC. Am J Psychiatry. 2002.
  • Slide 11 - Steinhausen HC. Am J Psychiatry. 2002.
  • Slide 12 - How many patients are treated against their will? Three studies done in the U.S. and Great Britain estimate that the proportion of anorexia patients in treatment who have not consented is between 9% and 16.6% Ramsey R et al. Br J Psychiatry. 1999.Crow SJ. Am J of Psychiatry. 2009. Royal College of Psychiatrists. Report from the Eating Disorders Special Interest Group of the Royal College of Psychiatrists. 2001.
  • Slide 13 - The central debate Can we force treatment on patients with anorexia when the patients appear to be competent and are refusing treatment?
  • Slide 14 - Elements of involuntary treatment Detention Forced self-feeding by mouth Feeding via nasogastric or intravenous tube Exercise restrictions Seclusion Withdrawal of other privileges Thiels C. Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2008.
  • Slide 15 - The “when” of involuntary treatment Treatment generally is imposed when “without further nutrition the anorexic will begin an irreversible decline to death” Draper H. Bioethics. 2000.
  • Slide 16 - Time Course and Phenomenology of Anorexia Nervosa and Bulimia Nervosa Kaye W. Am J Psychiatry. 2009.
  • Slide 17 - Proponents on both sides Heather Draper and Gunther Ratner argue that, with rare exceptions, we should not force treatment on patients with AN Jacinta Tan argues that there are many circumstances in which we should force such treatment on these patients
  • Slide 18 - Control and self-esteem “Control is the essence of the struggle in anorexia nervosa. Compulsory treatment may cause substantial injury to the already fragile self-esteem of anorexia nervosa patients. Autonomy should be maximized to avoid a situation in which the patient feels the only way to maintain some control over her life is by refusal of treatment.” Rathner G et al. Athlone Press. 1998.
  • Slide 19 - Respecting autonomy “Respecting autonomy means that we are bound to (make) our own moral decisions and others are bound not to interfere; but it also means that we are responsible for the decisions which we make.” Draper H. Bioethics. 2000.
  • Slide 20 - Two kinds of treatment refusal “…Two different kinds of refusal…may be confused in the assessment of a small minority of anorexics. The first is the refusal to eat, which may be regarded as involuntary and irrational. The second is the decision to refuse all therapy (including food) because the quality of life with anorexia is not good enough to outweigh the burdens of the therapy.” Draper H. Bioethics. 2000.
  • Slide 21 - Draper (cont’d) “…offering palliative care in such cases should not be dismissed as collusion with a mental illness. Rather, it should be seen as offering the same services to incurable anorexics as are available to others who cannot be cured.” Draper H. Bioethics. 2000.
  • Slide 22 - “We should be open to the possibility that sufferers are actually as competent as anyone else to make decisions about the quality of their lives, and to assess the relative value of their lives in the light of its quality “For this reason, it is proposed that it may be wrong, as well as unlawful, to force patients to comply with therapy simply because they are anorexic” Draper H. Bioethics. 2000.
  • Slide 23 - Some people disagree Jacinta Tan studied patients with AN Many reported impaired thinking skills and concentration Some patients, themselves, suggested that forced treatment may be appropriate under some circumstances
  • Slide 24 - Study questions Is it ever acceptable to force treatment on a sick person? On a person with a mental illness? In a person with anorexia? If so, when is it justified? When is such treatment effective?
  • Slide 25 - Values expressed by her subjects What does your anorexia nervosa mean to you? “It feels like my identity now…” “I remember getting some tests back saying how my liver was really damaged and all this, and I thought it was really rather good! ... It’s sick, isn’t it? It was like somehow I’d achieved!” “I wasn’t really bothered about dying, as long as I died thin.” Tan J. Philos Psychiatr Psychol. 2006.
  • Slide 26 - “When I haven’t got anyone forcing me to do anything, then I fight against my own thoughts, what my mind is telling me. Whereas when someone is forcing me to do something, then it makes it a hell of a lot easier to fight against them, and then in the end you’re fighting the wrong enemy.” - a patient Tan J. Philos Psychiatr Psychol. 2006.
  • Slide 27 - Control is complicated “Some participants found that being given freedom of choice was essential to allow them to disengage from fighting the professionals and reason out their treatment choices; others found that being faced with stark facts about the severity of the illness, or being confronted with the need for compulsory treatment, helped them to be able to decide to get better.” Tan J. Philos Psychiatr Psychol. 2006.
  • Slide 28 - PATIENT STATEMENTS “I think you're just so confused in your head that you need people to make the right decisions for you.” “I don’t know, but – once you’re up to healthy weight again, or, you can actually think better and concentrate longer, so you can see the sense of what’s being done to you.” “I think if somebody’s life is in danger and is threatened and they have to go into hospital then yes it’s very important to obviously re-feed them and to get them to a stage where they’re not, where they’re medically stable, but you can’t enter anybody into treatment if they’re not willing to.” “Although when I was back there [i.e., very ill] I’d say “No, that’s a stupid idea,” now being here I look back on it, I think “Hell yeah, you can’t not treat someone who’s going to die because they’re starving themselves.” Tan J. Philos Psychiatr Psychol. 2006.
  • Slide 29 - “Whatever their views about the use of compulsion in anorexia nervosa in general, or on issues of competence and capacity, all participants thought that it is right to impose treatment in order to save life.” Tan J. Int J Law Psychiatry. 2010.
  • Slide 30 - Tan (cont’d) What mattered most to participants was not whether they were compelled to have treatment, but the nature of their relationships with parents and mental-health professionals. Indeed, within a trusting relationship compulsion may be experienced as care. Tan J. Int J Law Psychiatry. 2010.
  • Slide 31 - Conclusions AN is a chronic illness with a high mortality rate Treatment is more effective early in the course of illness than late Coercive treatment early in the course of AN is justified because patients cannot assess the risks and benefits of their disease or treatment and because the prognosis for cure is good
  • Slide 32 - Conclusions When patients do not respond to initial treatment, their prognosis becomes much worse At some point, refractory AN may be considered a terminal or incurable illnesses In such cases, we should respect the patient’s refusal of treatment and initiate palliative care
  • Slide 33 - Resources Draper H. Treating anorexics without consent: some reservations. J Med Ethics. 1998;24:5-7. Rathner G. A Plea Against Compulsory Treatment for Anorexia Nervosa Patients In Vandereycken W, Beumont PVJ (eds): Treating Eating Disorders: Ethical, Legal and Personal Issues. Athlone Press. 1998. Tan J, Stewart A, Fitzpatrick R, Hope T. Attitudes of patients with anorexia nervosa to compulsory treatment and coercion. Int J Law Psychiatry. 2010 Jan;33(1):13-19. Tan J, Hope T, Stewart A, Fitzpatrick R. Competence to make treatment decisions in anorexia nervosa: thinking processes and values. Philos Psychiatr Psychol. 2006 Dec;13(4):267-282. Thiels C. Forced Treatment of Patients with Anorexia Nervosa. Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2008;21:495-498. Thiels C, Curtice M Jr. Forced Treatment in Patients with Anorexia Nervosa Pt 2. Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2009;22:497-500. Last updated 4/5/10
Obesity Free PowerPoint Template

Obesity

Views : 774

Germ Free PowerPoint Template

Germ

Views : 795

Maple Leaf Free PowerPoint Template

Maple Leaf

Views : 480

Open Book Free PowerPoint Template

Open Book

Views : 929

Easter Eggs Free PowerPoint Template

Easter Eggs

Views : 649

Light Abstract Free PowerPoint Template

Light Abstract

Views : 848

Room Interior Free PowerPoint Template

Room Interior

Views : 464

Laboratory Free PowerPoint Template

Laboratory

Views : 750

Construction Workers Free PowerPoint Template

Construction Workers

Views : 561

Sperm Free PowerPoint Template

Sperm

Views : 817

Coffee Bean Free PowerPoint Template

Coffee Bean

Views : 301

Happy Birthday Free PowerPoint Template

Happy Birthday

Views : 595

Unity Free PowerPoint Template

Unity

Views : 536

Keyboard Free PowerPoint Template

Keyboard

Views : 556

Orthodontist Free PowerPoint Template

Orthodontist

Views : 461

Massage SPA Free PowerPoint Template

Massage SPA

Views : 650

Heart Free PowerPoint Template

Heart

Views : 485

Credit Debit Card Free PowerPoint Template

Credit Debit Card

Views : 424

Firefighters Free PowerPoint Template

Firefighters

Views : 1270

Morning Running Free PowerPoint Template

Morning Running

Views : 771

Description : Available Forced treatment of anorexia nervosa powerpoint presentation for free download which is uploaded by honey an active user in belonging ppt presentation Health & Wellness category.

Tags : Forced treatment of anorexia nervosa

Shortcode : Get Shareable link